Seeing the local puppy costume contest brought a smile to my face! This group dressed up as the Scooby-Doo crew. When I was a student at Amherst College, there was a frequent rumor that the main characters in “Scooby-Doo” were based on the schools in the Five College Consortium. This unique collaboration in western Massachusetts means that students can all take courses at the other schools. It was said that Fred represented Amherst, Daphne was Mount Holyoke College, Velma was Smith College, Shaggy was Hampshire College, and Scooby-Doo was UMass Amherst. Although this was later disproved to be an urban legend, the story stuck around.
Hampshire College will officially close after the end of this semester in December 2026. In the 1950s, the presidents of the four other schools started a committee to examine what a liberal arts education should be. In 1965, Amherst alumnus Harold Johnson provided 6 million dollars to found Hampshire College, and five years later, the school admitted its first students. Alumni include filmmaker Ken Burns, actor Liev Schreiber (whom I have seen in the audience at NYC’s Shakespeare in the Park), and actress Lupita Nyong’o.
Hampshire offered a non-traditional curriculum: students did not choose a major or have specific course requirements; they created their own custom programs of study with faculty, focusing on independent projects. Instead of official grades, students were provided written assessments or project reviews by professors. When I reviewed applications for JD programs at NYU Law and Harvard Law, I remember being intrigued by these narrative evaluations for every class and project on Hampshire College student transcripts. I taught at independent schools before my admissions career, and I recall how it took much more effort to provide these comments than just simply assigning a grade for the term.
I chose a liberal arts education at Amherst as a teenager because I wanted the chance for an open curriculum without distribution requirements. Amherst is in a strong position, being in the top ten of American colleges in terms of the amount of endowment per student; with a 4.41 billion dollar endowment and about 1907 students, that comes out to over 2 million dollars per student. To put that into perspective, New York University has a 8.2 billion dollar endowment and with about 60,525 total students, which is only $135,481 per student.
However, liberal arts colleges are no longer as popular as they were a generation ago. Demographic shifts have meant a smaller traditional college-age population. Regional and small colleges especially have faced mounting pressures. Students have been more pre-professional in their focus, and perhaps transcripts without grades were more challenging in this environment. With changes facing higher education, unfortunately many more colleges and universities will end up closing in the future.
I hope that students will continue to expand their horizons and focus on core skills such as reading, writing, and critical thinking despite the pressures to specialize in a very career-oriented track and find a job after college.